Abstract
Used in combination with antiretroviral therapy, subcutaneous recombinant interleukin-2 raises CD4+ cell counts more than does antiretroviral therapy alone. The clinical implication of these increases is not known. We conducted two trials: the Subcutaneous Recombinant, Human Interleukin-2 in HIV-Infected Patients with Low CD4+ Counts under Active Antiretroviral Therapy (SILCAAT) study and the Evaluation of Subcutaneous Proleukin in a Randomized International Trial (ESPRIT). In each, patients infected with the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) who had CD4+ cell counts of either 50 to 299 per cubic millimeter (SILCAAT) or 300 or more per cubic millimeter (ESPRIT) were randomly assigned to receive interleukin-2 plus antiretroviral therapy or antiretroviral therapy alone. The interleukin-2 regimen consisted of cycles of 5 consecutive days each, administered at 8-week intervals. The SILCAAT study involved six cycles and a dose of 4.5 million IU of interleukin-2 twice daily; ESPRIT involved three cycles and a dose of 7.5 million IU twice daily. Additional cycles were recommended to maintain the CD4+ cell count above predefined target levels. The primary end point of both studies was opportunistic disease or death from any cause. In the SILCAAT study, 1695 patients (849 receiving interleukin-2 plus antiretroviral therapy and 846 receiving antiretroviral therapy alone) who had a median CD4+ cell count of 202 cells per cubic millimeter were enrolled; in ESPRIT, 4111 patients (2071 receiving interleukin-2 plus antiretroviral therapy and 2040 receiving antiretroviral therapy alone) who had a median CD4+ cell count of 457 cells per cubic millimeter were enrolled. Over a median follow-up period of 7 to 8 years, the CD4+ cell count was higher in the interleukin-2 group than in the group receiving antiretroviral therapy alone--by 53 and 159 cells per cubic millimeter, on average, in the SILCAAT study and ESPRIT, respectively. Hazard ratios for opportunistic disease or death from any cause with interleukin-2 plus antiretroviral therapy (vs. antiretroviral therapy alone) were 0.91 (95% confidence interval [CI], 0.70 to 1.18; P=0.47) in the SILCAAT study and 0.94 (95% CI, 0.75 to 1.16; P=0.55) in ESPRIT. The hazard ratios for death from any cause and for grade 4 clinical events were 1.06 (P=0.73) and 1.10 (P=0.35), respectively, in the SILCAAT study and 0.90 (P=0.42) and 1.23 (P=0.003), respectively, in ESPRIT. Despite a substantial and sustained increase in the CD4+ cell count, as compared with antiretroviral therapy alone, interleukin-2 plus antiretroviral therapy yielded no clinical benefit in either study. (ClinicalTrials.gov numbers, NCT00004978 [ESPRIT] and NCT00013611 [SILCAAT study].)
MeSH Terms
AIDS-Related Opportunistic Infections/epidemiology
Adult
Anti-Retroviral Agents/therapeutic use
Antiretroviral Therapy, Highly Active
CD4 Lymphocyte Count
Drug Therapy, Combination
Female
Follow-Up Studies
HIV/genetics,isolation & purification
HIV Infections/drug therapy,mortality,virology
Humans
Injections, Subcutaneous
Interleukin-2/administration & dosage,analogs & derivatives,therapeutic use
Male
RNA, Viral/blood
Recombinant Proteins/administration & dosage,therapeutic use
Chemicals
Anti-Retroviral Agents
Interleukin-2
RNA, Viral
Recombinant Proteins
aldesleukin
Authors & Affiliations
20 authors, click to expand affiliations / ORCID
INSIGHT-ESPRIT Study Group
SILCAAT Scientific Committee
Abrams D
Lévy Y
Losso M H
Babiker A
Collins G
Cooper D A
Darbyshire J
Emery S
Fox L
Gordin F
Lane H C
Lundgren J D
Mitsuyasu R
Neaton J D
Phillips A
Routy J P
Tambussi G
Wentworth D
Investigators
949 investigators, click to expand
Aagaard B
Aragon E
Arnaiz J
Borup L
Clotet B
Dragsted U
Fau A
Gey D
Grarup J
Hengge U
Herrero P
Jansson P
Jensen B
Jensen K
Juncher H
Lopez P
Lundgren J
Matthews C
Mollerup D
Pearson M
Phillips A
Reilev S
Tillmann K
Varea S
Angus B
Babiker A
Cordwell B
Darbyshire J
Dodds W
Fleck S
Horton J
Hudson F
Moraes Y
Pacciarini F
Palfreeman A
Paton N
Smith N
van Hooff F
Bebchuk J
Collins G
Denning E
DuChene A
Fosdick L
Harrison M
Herman-Lamin K
Krum E
Larson G
Neaton J
Nelson R
Quan K
Quan S
Schultz T
Thompson G
Wentworth D
Wyman N
Carey C
Chan F
Cooper D
Cordwell B
Courtney-Rodgers D
Drummond F
Emery S
Harrod M
Jacoby S
Kearney L
Law M
Lin E
Pett S
Robson R
Seneviratne N
Stewart M
Watts E
Finley E
Gordin F
Sánchez A
Standridge B
Vjecha M
Belloso W
Davey R
Duprez D
Gatell J
Hoy J
Lifson A
Pederson C
Perez G
Price R
Prineas R
Rhame F
Sampson J
Worley J
Modlin J
Beral V
Chaisson R
Fleming T
Hill C
Kim K
Murray B
Pick B
Seligmann M
Weller I
Cahill K
Fox L
Luzar M
Martinez A
McNay L
Pierson J
Tierney J
Vogel S
Costas V
Eckstrand J
Brown S
Abusamra L
Angel E
Aquilia S
Belloso W
Benetucci J
Bittar V
Bogdanowicz E
Cahn P
Casiro A
Contarelli J
Corral J
Daciuk L
David D
Dobrzanski W
Duran A
Ebenrstejin J
Ferrari I
Fridman D
Galache V
Guaragna G
Ivalo S
Krolewiecki A
Lanusse I
Laplume H
Lasala M
Lattes R
Lazovski J
Lopardo G
Losso M
Lourtau L
Lupo S
Maranzana A
Marson C
Massera L
Moscatello G
Olivia S
Otegui I
Palacios L
Parlante A
Salomon H
Sanchez M
Somenzini C
Suarez C
Tocci M
Toibaro J
Zala C
Agrawal S
Ambrose P
Anderson C
Anderson J
Baker D
Beileiter K
Blavius K
Bloch M
Boyle M
Bradford D
Britton P
Brown P
Busic T
Cain A
Carrall L
Carson S
Chenoweth I
Chuah J
Clark F
Clemons J
Clezy K
Cooper D
Cortissos P
Cunningham N
Curry M
Daly L
D'Arcy-Evans C
Del Rosario R
Dinning S
Dobson P
Donohue W
Doong N
Downs C
Edwards E
Edwards S
Egan C
Ferguson W
Finlayson R
Forsdyke C
Foy L
Franic T
Frater A
French M
Gleeson D
Gold J
Habel P
Haig K
Hardy S
Holland R
Hoy J
Hudson J
Hutchison R
Hyland N
James R
Johnston C
Kelly M
King M
Kunkel K
Lau H
Leamy J
Lester D
Leung J
Lohmeyer A
Lowe K
MacRae K
Magness C
Martinez O
Maruszak H
Medland N
Miller S
Murray J
Negus P
Newman R
Ngieng M
Nowlan C
Oddy J
Orford N
Orth D
Patching J
Plummer M
Price S
Primrose R
Prone I
Ree H
Remington C
Richardson R
Robinson S
Rogers G
Roney J
Roth N
Russell D
Ryan S
Sarangapany J
Schmidt T
Schneider K
Shields C
Silberberg C
Shaw D
Skett J
Smith D
Soo T Meng
Sowden D
Street A
Tee B Kiem
Thomson J I
Topaz S
Vale R
Villella C
Walker A
Watson A
Wendt N
Williams L
Youds D
Aichelburg A
Cichon P
Gemeinhart B
Rieger A
Schmied B
Touzeau-Romer V
Vetter N
Colebunders R
Clumeck N
DeRoo A
Kabeya K
O'Doherty E
de Wit S
Amorim C De Salles
Basso C
Flint S
Kallas E
Levi G
Lewi D
Pereira L
da Silva M
Souza T
Toscano A
Angel J
Arsenault M
Bast M
Beckthold B
Bouchard P
Chabot I
Clarke R
Cohen J
Coté P
Ellis M
Gagne C
Gill J
Houde M
Johnston B
Jubinville N
Kato C
Lamoureux N
Larson G
Latendre-Paquette J
Lindemulder A
McNeil A
McFarland N
Montaner J
Morrisseau C
O'Neill R
Page G
Piche A
Pongracz B
Preziosi H
Puri L
Rachlis A
Ralph E
Raymond I
Rouleau D
Routy J P
Sandre R
Seddon T
Shafran S
Sikora C
Smaill F
Stromberg D
Trottier S
Walmsley S
Weiss K
Williams K
Zarowny D
Baadegaard B
Andersen A Bengaard
Boedker K
Collins P
Gerstoft J
Jensen L
Moller H
Andersen P Lehm
Loftheim I
Mathiesen L
Nielsen H
Obel N
Pedersen C
Petersen D
Jensen L Pors
Black F Trunk
Aboulker J P
Aouba A
Bensalem M
Berthe H
Blanc C
Bloch M
Bornarel D
Bouchaud O
Boue F
Bouvet E
Brancon C
Breaud S
Brosseau D
Brunet A
Capitant C
Ceppi C
Chakvetadze C
Cheneau C
Chennebault J M
De Truchis P
Delavalle A M
Delfraissy J F
Dellamonica P
Delavalle A M
Dumont C
Edeb N
Fabre G
Ferrando S
Foltzer A
Foubert V
Gastaut J A
Gerbe J
Girard P M
Goujard C
Hoen B
Honore P
Hue H
Hynh T
Jung C
Kahi S
Katlama C
Lang J M
Le Baut V
Lefebvre B
Leturque N
Lévy Y
Loison J
Maddi G
Maignan A
Majerholc C
de Boever C
Meynard J L
Michelet C
Michon C
Mole M
Netzer E
Pialoux G
Poizot-Martin I
Raffi F
Ratajczak M
Ravaux I
Reynes J
Salmon-Ceron D
Sebire M
Simon A
Tegna L
Tisne-Dessus D
Tramoni C
Viard J P
Vidal M
Viet-Peaucelle C
Weiss L
Zeng A
Zucman D
Adam A
Arastéh K
Behrens G
Bergmann F
Bickel M
Bittner D
Bogner J
Brockmeyer N
Darrelmann N
Deja M
Doerler M
Esser S
Faetkenheuer G
Fenske S
Gajetzki S
Gey D
Goebel F
Gorriahn D
Harrer E
Harrer T
Hartl H
Hartmann M
Heesch S
Jakob W
Jäger H
Klinker H
Kremer G
Ludwig C
Mantzsch K
Mauss S
Meurer A
Niedermeier A
Pittack N
Plettenberg A
Potthoff A
Probst M
Rittweger M
Rockstroh J
Ross B
Rotty J
Rund E
Ruzicka T
Schmidt R T
Schmutz G
Schnaitmann E
Schuster D
Sehr T
Spaeth B
Staszewski S
Stellbrink H J
Stephan C
Stockey T
Stoehr A
Tillmann K
Trein A
Vaeth T
Vogel M
Wasmuth J
Wengenroth C
Winzer R
Wolf E
Mulcahy F
Reidy D I
Cohen Y
Drora G
Eliezer I
Godo O
Kedem E
Magen E
Mamorsky M
Pollack S
Sthoeger Z
Vered H
Yust I
Aiuti F
Bechi M
Bergamasco A
Bertelli D
Bruno R
Butini L
Cagliuso M
Carosi G
Casari S
Chrysoula V
Cologni G
Conti V
Costantini A
Corpolongo A
D'Offizi G
Gaiottino F
Di Pietro M
Esposito R
Filice G
Francesco M
Gianelli E
Graziella C
Magenta L
Martellotta F
Maserati R
Mazzotta F
Murdaca G
Nardini G
Nozza S
Puppo F
Pogliaghi M
Ripamonti D
Ronchetti C
Rusconi S
Rusconi V
Sacchi P
Silvia N
Suter F
Tambussi G
Uglietti A
Vechi M
Vergani B
Vichi F
Vitiello P
Iwamoto A
Kikuchi Y
Miyazaki N
Mori M
Nakamura T
Odawara T
Oka S
Shirasaka T
Tabata M
Takano M
Ueta C
Watanabe D
Yamamoto Y
Erradey I
Himmich H
El Filali K Marhoum
Blok W
van Boxtel R
Doevelaar K Brinkman H
van Eeden A
Grijsen M
Groot M
Juttmann J
Kuipers M
Ligthart S
van der Meulen P
Lange J
Langebeek N
Ligthart S
Reiss P
Richter C
Schoemaker M
Schrijnders-Gudde L
Septer-Bijleveld E
Sprenger H
Vermeulen J
ten Kate R
van de Ven B
Bruun J
Kvale D
Maeland A
Bakowska E
Beniowski M
Boron-Kaczmarska A
Gasiorowski J
Horban A
Inglot M
Knysz B
Mularska E
Parczewski M
Pynka M
Rymer W
Szymczak A
Aldir M
Antunes F
Baptista C
Vera J da Conceicao
Doroana M
Mansinho K
dos Santos C Raquel A
Valadas E
Pinto I Vaz
Chia E
Foo E
Karim F
Lim P L
Panchalingam A
Paton N
Quek A
Alcázar-Caballero R
Aragon E
Arnaiz J
Arrizabalaga J
de Barron X
Blanco F
Bouza E
Bravo I
Calvo S
Carbonero L
Carpena I
Castro M
Clotet B
Cortes L
del Toro M
Domingo P
Elias M
Espinosa J
Estrada V
Fernandez-Cruz E
Fernández P
Freud H
Fuster M
Garcia A
Garcia G
Garrido R
Gatell J
Gijón P
Gonzalez-García J
Gil I
González A
González-Lahoz J
López Grosso P
Gutierrez M
Guzmán E
Iribarren J
Jiménez M
Jou A
Juega J
Lopez J
Lopez P
Lozano F
Martín-Carbonero L
Mata R
Mateo G
Menasalvas A
Mirelles C
de Miguel Prieto J
Montes M
Moreno A
Moreno J
Moreno V
Muñoz R
Ocampo A
Ortega E
Ortiz L
Padilla B
Parras A
Paster A
Pedreira J
Peña J
Perea R
Portas B
Puig J
Pulido F
Rebollar M
de Rivera J
Roca V
Rodríguez- Arrondo F
Rubio R
Santos J
Sanz J
Sebastian G
Segovia M
Soriano V
Tamargo L
Varea S
Viciana P
von Wichmann M
Bratt G
Hollander A
Pehrson P Olov
Petz I
Sandstrom E
Sönnerborg A
Bernasconi E
Gurtner V
Ampunpong U
Auchieng C
Bowonwatanuwong C
Chanchai P
Chetchotisakd P
Chuenyan T
Duncombe C
Horsakulthai M
Kantipong P
Laohajinda K
Phanuphak P
Pongsurachet V
Pradapmook S
Ruxruntham K
Seekaew S
Sonjai A
Suwanagool S
Techasathit W
Ubolyam S
Wankoon J
Alexander I
Dockrell D
Easterbrook P
Edwards B
Evans E
Fisher M
Fox R
Gazzard B
Gilleran G
Hand J
Heald L
Higgs C
Jeakumar S
Jendrulek I
Johnson M
Johnson S
Karim F
Kinghorn G
Kuldanek K
Leen C
Maw R
McKernan S
McLean L
Morris S
Murphy M
O'Farrell S
Ong E
Peters B
Stroud C
Wansbrough-Jones M
Weber J
White D
Williams I
Wiselka M
Yee T
Adams S
Allegra D
Andrews L
Aneja B
Anstead G
Arduino R
Artz R
Bailowitz J
Banks S
Baxter J
Baum J
Benator D
Black D
Boh D
Bonam T
Brito M
Brockelman J
Brown S
Bruzzese V
Burnside A
Cafaro V
Casey K
Cason L
Childress G
Clark C I
Clifford D
Climo M
Cohn D
Couey P
Cuervo H
Davey R
Deeks S
Dennis M
Diaz-Linares M
Dickerson D
Diez M
Di Puppo J
Dodson P
Dupre D
Elion R
Elliott K
El-Sadr W
Estes M
Fabre J
Farrough M
Flamm J
Follansbee S
Foster C
Frank C
Franz J
Frechette G
Freidland G
Frische J
Fuentes L
Funk C
Geisler C
Genther K
Giles M
Goetz M
Gonzalez M
Graeber C
Graziano F
Grice D
Hahn B
Hamilton C
Hassler S
Henson A
Hopper S
John M
Johnson L
Johnson M
Johnson R
Jones R
Kahn J
Kelly M
Klimas N
Kolber M
Koletar S
Labriola A
Larsen R
Lasseter F
Lederman M
Ling T
Lusch T
MacArthur R
Machado C
Makohon L
Mandelke J
Mannheimer S
Markowitz N
Martínez M
Martinez N
Mass M
Masur H
McGregor D
McIntyre D
McKee J
McMullen D
Mettinger M
Middleton S
Mieras J
Mildvan D
Miller P
Miller T
Mitchell V
Mitsuyasu R
Moanna A
Mogridge C
Moran F
Murphy R
Mushatt D
Nahass R
Nixon D
O'Brien S
Ojeda J
Okhuysen P
Olson M
Osterberger J
Owen W
Pablovich S
Patel S
Perez G
Pierone G
Poblete R
Potter A
Preston E
Rappoport C
Regevik N
Reyelt M
Rhame F
Riney L
Rodriguez-Barradas M
Rodriguez M
Rodriguez Milagros
Rodriguez J
Roland R
Rosmarin-DeStefano C
Rossen W
Rouff J
Saag M
Sampson J
Santiago S
Sarria J
Wirtz S
Schmidt U
Scott C
Sheridan A
Shin A
Shrader S
Simon G
Slowinski D
Smith K
Spotkov J
Sprague C
States D
Suh C
Sullivan J
Summers K
Sweeton B
Tan V
Tanner T
Tedaldi E
Temesgen Z
Thomas D
Thompson M
Tobin C
Toro N
Towner W
Upton K
Uy J
Valenti S
van der Horst C
Vita J
Voell J
Walker J
Walton T
Wason K
Watson V
Wellons A
Weise J
White M
Whitman T
Williams B
Williams N
Windham J
Witt M
Workowski K
Wortmann G
Wright T
Zelasky C
Zwickl B
References (26)
26 references, click to expand
-
Clinical progression rates by CD4 cell category before and after the initiation of combination antiretroviral therapy (cART).
Open AIDS J. 2008;2:3-9
PMID: 18923700
-
Enhanced T cell recovery in HIV-1-infected adults through IL-7 treatment.
J Clin Invest. 2009 Apr;119(4):997-1007
PMID: 19287090
-
Immunologic and virologic effects of subcutaneous interleukin 2 in combination with antiretroviral therapy: A randomized controlled trial.
JAMA. 2000 Jul 12;284(2):183-9
PMID: 10889591
-
Comparison of subcutaneous and intravenous interleukin-2 in asymptomatic HIV-1 infection: a randomised controlled trial. ANRS 048 study group.
Lancet. 1999 Jun 5;353(9168):1923-9
PMID: 10371571
-
A randomized, controlled, phase II trial comparing escalating doses of subcutaneous interleukin-2 plus antiretrovirals versus antiretrovirals alone in human immunodeficiency virus-infected patients with CD4+ cell counts >/=350/mm3.
J Infect Dis. 2000 May;181(5):1614-21
PMID: 10823761
-
CD4 cell response to 3 doses of subcutaneous interleukin 2: meta-analysis of 3 Vanguard studies.
Clin Infect Dis. 2004 Jul 1;39(1):115-22
PMID: 15206062
-
CD4+ T cell responses to interleukin-2 administration in HIV-infected patients are directly related to the baseline level of immune activation.
J Infect Dis. 2007 Sep 1;196(5):677-83
PMID: 17674308
-
Randomized, open-label study of the impact of two doses of subcutaneous recombinant interleukin-2 on viral burden in patients with HIV-1 infection and CD4+ cell counts of > or = 300/mm3: CPCRA 059.
J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr. 2002 Mar 1;29(3):221-31
PMID: 11873071
-
An evaluation of HIV RNA and CD4 cell count as surrogates for clinical outcome. Delta Coordinating Committee and Virology Group.
AIDS. 1999 Apr 1;13(5):565-73
PMID: 10203381
-
Increases in CD4 T lymphocytes with intermittent courses of interleukin-2 in patients with human immunodeficiency virus infection. A preliminary study.
N Engl J Med. 1995 Mar 2;332(9):567-75
PMID: 7646637
-
Surrogate end points in clinical trials: are we being misled?
Ann Intern Med. 1996 Oct 1;125(7):605-13
PMID: 8815760
-
Pooled analysis of 3 randomized, controlled trials of interleukin-2 therapy in adult human immunodeficiency virus type 1 disease.
J Infect Dis. 2000 Aug;182(2):428-34
PMID: 10915072
-
Inflammatory and coagulation biomarkers and mortality in patients with HIV infection.
PLoS Med. 2008 Oct 21;5(10):e203
PMID: 18942885
-
Effects of interleukin-2 therapy combined with highly active antiretroviral therapy on immune restoration in HIV-1 infection: a randomized controlled trial.
AIDS. 2003 Feb 14;17(3):343-51
PMID: 12556688
-
CD4 T cell survival after intermittent interleukin-2 therapy is predictive of an increase in the CD4 T cell count of HIV-infected patients.
J Infect Dis. 2008 Sep 15;198(6):843-50
PMID: 18684102
-
A randomized, controlled 24-week study of intermittent subcutaneous interleukin-2 in HIV-1 infected patients in Thailand.
AIDS. 2000 Nov 10;14(16):2509-13
PMID: 11101062
-
The virologic, immunologic, and clinical effects of interleukin 2 with potent antiretroviral therapy in patients with moderately advanced human immunodeficiency virus infection: a randomized controlled clinical trial--AIDS Clinical Trials Group 328.
Arch Intern Med. 2007 Mar 26;167(6):597-605
PMID: 17389292
-
The evaluation of subcutaneous proleukin (interleukin-2) in a randomized international trial: rationale, design, and methods of ESPRIT.
Control Clin Trials. 2002 Apr;23(2):198-220
PMID: 11943448
-
A randomized controlled trial evaluating the efficacy and safety of intermittent 3-, 4-, and 5-day cycles of intravenous recombinant human interleukin-2 combined with antiretroviral therapy (ART) versus ART alone in HIV-seropositive patients with 100-300 CD4+ T cells.
Clin Immunol. 2003 Mar;106(3):188-96
PMID: 12706405
-
Controlled trial of interleukin-2 infusions in patients infected with the human immunodeficiency virus.
N Engl J Med. 1996 Oct 31;335(18):1350-6
PMID: 8857018
-
CD4 cell count as a surrogate endpoint in HIV clinical trials: a meta-analysis of studies of the AIDS Clinical Trials Group.
AIDS. 1998 Oct 1;12(14):1823-32
PMID: 9792383
-
Underestimation of risk associations due to regression dilution in long-term follow-up of prospective studies.
Am J Epidemiol. 1999 Aug 15;150(4):341-53
PMID: 10453810
-
The role of HIV in serious diseases other than AIDS.
AIDS. 2008 Nov 30;22(18):2409-18
PMID: 19005264
-
IL-2-induced CD4+ T-cell expansion in HIV-infected patients is associated with long-term decreases in T-cell proliferation.
Blood. 2004 Aug 1;104(3):775-80
PMID: 15090457
-
Induction of prolonged survival of CD4+ T lymphocytes by intermittent IL-2 therapy in HIV-infected patients.
J Clin Invest. 2005 Aug;115(8):2139-48
PMID: 16025158
-
Outpatient continuous intravenous interleukin-2 or subcutaneous, polyethylene glycol-modified interleukin-2 in human immunodeficiency virus-infected patients: a randomized, controlled, multicenter study. Australian IL-2 Study Group.
J Infect Dis. 1998 Oct;178(4):992-9
PMID: 9806026